The LookOut Letters to the Editor
Speak Out!  E-mail us at : Editor@surfsantamonica.com

 

Dec 10, 1999

Dear Editor,

To the SMMUSD Board of Education and Dr. Schmidt:

Our family moved to this area from a suburb of Philadelphia two years ago. Despite numerous friends' warnings about the sorry state of public education and its funding in California, we rejected private schools and opted to live in Santa Monica so we could send our children to public school here. Certainly, we were attracted by the quality of the academics, but we were especially drawn by the outstanding music program. Imagine our shock to learn that the elementary music program is now threatened.

It is difficult to convey what playing the violin, and exposure to music more generally, has done for our 11-year old daughter (a sixth grader on the Concert Orchestra at Lincoln). Involvement in music has fostered our daughter's self-confidence, poise, and interest in the arts. It has helped her develop discipline, good study habits, and a belief in the value of hard work. It has helped her understand that teamwork is about individuals with diverse talents coming together to create a larger whole. It has helped her develop an appreciation for positive aspects of our culture. Imagine a sixth grader who goes around the house humming Vivaldi, or whose favorite compact disc is Bach's double
concerto, or who thinks that Mozart led a fascinating life.

Imagine a sixth grader whose favorite school day is Thursday, because that is the day the Lincoln Concert Orchestra rehearses. Imagine a sixth grader who looks forward to high school so she can be on the Symphony Orchestra and
travel to Chicago. And we know that our daughter is not alone.

The feature that makes the SMMUSD different is the music program. Stairway to the Stars is a unique, magnificent, awe-inspiring spectacle that demonstrates what children are capable of when they are engaged, stimulated, and taught and directed by adults who love what they do.

Eliminating the elementary school component of the music program would eat away at the core of the district's (and the city's) personality and values, and would have ripple effects on the students for years to come. A good education is about many things, including instruction in the music and arts that both reflect and shape our traditions and culture. To paraphrase Richard Dreyfuss in the movie "Mr. Holland's Opus," if you teach reading and writing but take away music and the arts, soon children will have very little to read or write about.

Please preserve the elementary music program. Please do the right thing for the city, the district, and, most of all, the children.

Sincerely,

Jose and Eileen Escarce
Parents of a Lincoln 6th grader and a Franklin 2nd grader


Dec 10, 1999

Dear Board Members,

My son is in the Music program at Lincoln Middle school, and his brother in the 4th grade has recently taken up the clarinet at Franklin. What message will the Board of Education send to the current 4th graders who have enthusiastically started the program?!! The message will be:

The adults in my community do not follow through on their commitments to me!

Unfortunately, they will be right. Please save the Elementary Music Program.

Thank-you,
Patricia Bentivoglio


Dec 10, 1999

Dear gentlemen and ladies,

Just last night I attended the holiday concert at Lincoln Middle School, where my seventh grade daughter played clarinet in the Concert Band. She began her musical education at Franklin Elementary School in the fourth grade, and has never taken private lessons. If you eliminate music education in the elementary schools, you are SEVERELY damaging the quality of future bands and orchestras at Lincoln, John Adams, and Santa Monica High. You will also be damaging child development of such skills as discipline, practice, teamwork, and enchancing self esteem.

This will be an absolute disaster that you have the power and presige to avoid. My son is a fourth grade student who has just taken up the clarinet and performed in his first concert last week, where he played a composition that he wrote himself. I have never seen him look prouder. DON'T deprive
him and hundreds of other children of these powerul experiences.

All eyes are on you. Please come through!

Bennett Tramer


Dec 10, 1999

Dear friends,

My earliest childhood memories are of the joys school music imparted to me. Songs I learned in elementary school remain in my heart, where many other things learned there have evaporated into the mists of time.

Please, please give the gift of music to today's children, so that they may carry that inspiration and strength into the challenges of the 21st century.

Sincerely,

Rosalie Grace Heacock
31960 Pacific Coast Highway
Malibu, CA 90265
310-589-0444


Dec 10, 1999

As a longtime resident of Santa Monica, I want to express my support of
the elementrary school music program-- my three kids have all graduated
from Samohi, so it does not affect me personally, but the start they got
in elementary school carried through to some important educational
lessons in working hard, teamwork and to many rewarding musical
experiences later on. The music program is something all of Santa
Monica can be proud of, and is definitely worth supporting.

Emmett Keeler
402 15th St


Dec 10, 1999

Are you all so behind the times to start cutting music programs? Haven't you been reading articles on how important music is in the development of
mathematics and in self-esteem? Haven't you seen "Music of the Heart" in the movie theatres and a TV movie about music programs that do so much for the students?

Please think again about cutting the instrumental music program in elementary, or any school level in Santa Monica. Your school district is known for its
specialties and that's why people with children move into Santa Monica. Do you want to become just another school district?

Music has found to have a lot of importance in peoples lives, self-esteem, helping with intellectual thinking, getting through to trouble children, etc. It's
not a frill subject. My daughter is in college studying Music Therapy because she is passionate about her vocal musical talent, (that she majored in, in high school), and she wanted to do something with it for others.

So think twice, three times, even four times before cutting the music
programs from SMUSD.

Sincerely,

Kathy Rosenblatt
Parent of College Students
1171 Stearns Drive
Los Angeles, CA 90035
(323) 939-4767


Dec 10, 1999

Dear Board Members:
Many proponents of early music education cite recent research on the benefits of music to a child's cognitive development. Music education also helps children's coordination and motor development. And, of course, exposure to the art of good music is, like virtue, its own reward.

If those are not compelling enough to preserve the elementary music program intact, consider the civilizing benefits of music education. Playing an instrument gives an outlet for emotions that might otherwise fester or be difficult to express in words. Playing with others fosters socialization. Playing with others in harmony engenders respect for the other guy. Since schools in our society are charged with a civilizing role, music education seems integral to a school's duties, and serves that function in a way that the three R's can't.

I urge you to restore the full budget for the music education program.

Christine Taylor


Dec 10, 1999

I am writing to urge you to reconsider your funding cuts of the SMUSD
elementary school music program. I work in Santa Monica and my son went
to elementary school here for a few years, and when we transferred him to our home district (Manhattan Beach) one of my goals was to help initiate an elementary music performance group in our schools that was comparable to yours in Santa Monica. We did achieve that goal, and the program has been hugely successful in so many ways. We have active bands in almost all of our elementary schools, our middle school, and our high school, and we have just started a string program to prepare for a school orchestra program. Our high school band, which only about 10 years ago was practically nonexistent, is now at nearly 100 members and plays at many community events and marching band competitions.

The benefits of these programs have been innumerable. Besides the obvious gain of music appreciation, participation in these groups has engendered a tremendous sense of spirit and cohesiveness among the students, their parents, and our whole community. My son is now in the high school marching and jazz bands, and his participation in band events and his friendships among the band members are at the core of his high school experience.

It really saddens me that your district, which has enjoyed the benefits of these music programs for so long, is prepared to cut them off. I would hope that you
would think long and hard about all possible ways to fund this and the other
arts programs. In Manhattan Beach, we have an Education Foundation which has helped provide funds for some of our music and art programs; if Santa Monica does not have such an organization, you might consider initiating one.

In any case, I truly hope you can find a way to continue your support of music and art in your district, because their loss would make your schools much poorer in the ways that really count.

Thanks very much-
Roberta Shanman


Dec 10, 1999

Although I don't have kids in the Santa Monica school system, I strongly recommend retaining the music budget at all educational levels. Studies have shown that participating in any form of musical education enhances logical and analytical thinking as well as creativity. Cutting the music budget could have negative effects on overall academic scores.

Of course, music enriches everyone's life. Providing musical training at all levels provides the foundation for a fuller life and deeer appreciation of all art forms.

Regards,

Mary Bernstein
(310) 390 4954


Dec 10, 1999

Gentlepeople:

I am a 30 year resident of the City of Santa Monica, whose children are grown and live in other parts of California. However, I am concerned regarding the cutbacks in the music program of our schools.

Please do all you can to promote the love and understanding of music for our school children. I had the advantage of belonging to glee clubs and other choral groups throughout my life. It has been one of the biggest pleasures of my life to sing and enjoy music. I am still an active choir member of my church. This is especially notable since I have never been able to read music.

I was a child of the depression and there was no money for special instruction, so the public school was IT! When I think of how many years of pleasure and enrichment of my life has been mine, mainly because of my school experience, I can't imagine depriving our school children of their same enjoyment. Thank you.

Edith Nichols


Dec 10, 1999

Dear SMMUSD School Board Members,

We are living in Yale Street 1139, #3 Santa Monica. Our kid is in 4th grade
in Franklin elementary school. We have heard that the elementary school
music program is about to be cut. We are very concerned about it. The music
program in Santa Monica is well known for years and that is one of the key
reason we want to stay in Santa Monica. I have met with other parents, a lot
of the families want to stay in Santa Monica and have their kids to the public school because of the same reason - the well known music program in
Santa Monica public school.

Canceling the elementary music program will bring a huge ramification to
Santa Monica School system. Elementary music program is just like a nutrient
to a new born baby. Without properly nurturing the baby, he or she will not
grow up healthily. If the elementary music program is eliminated, kids from
poor families will not have a chance to participate, they will not be able to
catch up when they start music lessons in middle school. They will be left
behind and are not able to join band or orchestra. Kids from rich families may have private lessons but they will not have a place to work together and to perform together. They will not have any competition, they will not need to work hard, and they do not have fun to do their music practice.

Its reputation and its excellence in music education is a valuable piece in Santa Monica public school system, we need to do something to keep it.

Thanks & regards,

Kathy & Simon Siu


Dec 10, 1999

Dear School Board Members,
I am a resident of Santa Monica, and while I do not have children, I believe that access to music education through the public schools and at an early age is vitally important. I urge you not to cut the music education program in Santa Monica's elementary schools.

I myself started playing violin at age 4; while I did not become a professional musician, it opened up a new world for myself and my siblings. I was lucky enough to have parents who could afford private lessons; many children do not--their only access to music education is through the public schools.

Sincerely,
Caroline Danielson


Dec 10, 1999

Dear Gentlemen and Ladies,

My daughter is part of the wonderful Symphony Orchestra going to Chicago next week. Have you stopped and listened to this incredible group of musicians?

Please do not rid of the music program at Samohi. Music and Art and Theatre
help kids to grow and learn real culture. When any of you find yourselves
wondering what to do on a weekend, I'm sure you find yourself at an art
gallery, a play or a visit to the Philharmonic or ballet if you can. By
keeping these programs you allow these kids to learn the fundamentals of the
arts -- Arts that they will experience and enjoy constantly in their adult
life.

The music program has enriched my daughter's life and my oun.

Thank you for your consideration.

Larry Shulman
310-998-5069


Dec 10, 1999

I am a music teacher/composer currently teaching guitar privately in the S.M area. It is sad to see a good school system disregard the importance of fine
arts in education. It is embarrassing to read that music in schools is
"discretionary" I am interested in helping out in some constructive way.
Thanks. Joseph Digati


Dec 10, 1999

To the Board of Education, Santa Monica Malibu Unified School District:

We urge you to find a more realistic solution to the budget crisis you have
got our district into. Surely your purpose is to serve the best interest of
the children of those who elected you. Cutting any portion of the Music
Program would be an injustice.

There other alternatives to solving the problem, explore each and everyone of
them.

"Let the Music - play on"


Graham & Debra Wong


Dec 10, 1999

To whom it may concern,
I would love to see which of you endorsing the cutting of arts programs from
The Santa Monica School system would have the spine to stand before a group of SMMUSD Alums, Parent of SMMUSD students, and the Student body to defend your outrageous proposals to cut the fine arts programs. I doubt seriously any of you could look a group of concerned citizens straight in the eye and do such a thing. It is preposterous that anyone would consider cutting back on such programs in this day and age. Clearly the young people in SM, and everywhere need more exposure to the arts, not less.

I received my early music training in the Santa Monica School system. At
McKinley elementary, Lincoln Jr High, and Samohi, as well as continuing on at
Santa Monica College. This solid background in Music has been the
cornerstone of both my life and livelihood. I was fortunate enough to
graduate from Samohi in '78, pre prop 13 cutbacks, so I knew I was one of the last of a very privileged couple of generations to have had access to such
wonderful schools. I just wish whoever it is that takes such great
devastating swipes at what was once a true gem in the California schools had
some modicum of respect for actual education. I urge all of you politicians
and school board members to snap out of it and get to your real job of taking
care of the future of our state and country by taking care of the young
people who so richly deserve a true education. Quit hacking at the already
undernourished schools and start building them back up. Earn you r damn
money!!!

Paul J. Olguin


Dec 10, 1999

I am a product of the SMUSD. I started in band in fourth grade at Franklin and continued through Lincoln and SAMO. I later played with USC's Concert Band and now ,at nearly 40 , enjoy playing as a hobby with bands in night clubs on a regular basis.

I can clearly say the education at the elementary level was valuable
even before band started in 4th grade.Children would participate in Choir in
3rd grade. A piano would be rolled into the classroom and a music teacher
would come in and sing songs. The Autoharp was played by the music teacher
played as the children sang together in 1st and 2nd grade. All these things
in Elementary music are the foundations to later development in music.
Studies have shown that the best success for learning an instrument (to grasp
the concept) is before the age of 12 . Music is also a easy and fun way to
reinforce math concepts.

In my entire SMUSD education, the moment that stands out the most, is
when my music teacher, Mr. Schartz, took the personal time to show me one on one how to play the saxophone.This meant more to me than any other experience going to all my classes in 13 years from K-12 in SM Schools.
I am a business owner in SM and contribute as a tax payor to operate
in SM. It would be shame to see any cuts take place in any music program in
SMUSD. My tax dollars pay your salaries. Perhaps a salary cut is in order
first before music if you care about why you really took on your job. The next election may not be so kind to you.

Albert Rappoport


Dec 10, 1999

Dear public official:

How often do we have to revisit the issue of whether art and music are
important to the lives of our young people. We cannot afford to let a
generation of students suffer from the deprivation of such elevating
activities as making music in a public school setting. Santa Monica has
developed a well-deserved reputation for its music programs. Let's
strengthen, not dismantle them.

Sincerely,

Richard Grayson
Professor of Music
Occidental College


Dec 10, 1999

Members of the SMMUSD Board,

I have been made aware of the fact that there is a possibility that the
music programs of the district may ba canceled due to a lack of funds.
As a graduate of Lincoln Junior High ('69) and Santa Monica High School
('72) it is my hope that this tragedy can be avoided.

As a student, I was involved in sports, government, clubs but .... it is
the music, the Band specifically, that I remember most and best. I still
play today and there have been a few "dark times" in my life that, were
it not for the ability to express myself through my music, I do not know
how I would have made it to the other side of the abyss.

Is the Board aware of just how many Samohi graduates have gone on to
make the "making of music" a major part of there lives? The truth be
known, there are university, community as well as major symphony
orchestras and countless bands that count Samohi alum's among their
members.

As a member of the G.A.T.E. (gifted and talented education) Advisory
Board for the San Jose Unified School District, I urge you.....

DON'T LET THE MUSIC DIE!

Cordially,

Hilton "Skip" Graef '72


Dec 10, 1999

Dear Board Members,
My name is Brittany Graves, I am in 8 th grade at John Adams Middle
School and a percussionist is our Wind Ensemble. I have been playing
percussion for my 3 years at John Adams (and I played the violin for 2 years
at Grant) and hope to continue in high school. I believe that you should not
cut the music in elementary schools music programs because that is where our
kids get their start on music.

Just look at our high school (SAMOHI) and how good all the musicians are there. Do you know where they started to become what they are now? Yeah, that's right elementary school. As most of you know SAMOHI Orchestra is performing at Chicago's prestigious Midwest Clinic music convention, not to mention that this is the first time a California public high school has been invited there in half a century. And once again the kids in this ensemble have probably started in elementary school. I know that I have probable repeated myself over and over again, but I am hoping that I got my message across to you to
not .......... CUT MUSIC FROM ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I really hope that you will/would consider you opions/desisions!!


Thank You For Your Time,
Brittany Graves
8 th grade percussionist at John Adams Middle School


Copyright ©1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003 surfsantamonica.com.
All Rights Reserved.